Picture of Louis Cosenza

Has Science Outstripped the Law of Biological Parenthood?

Two unusual cases affecting the legal status of same sex partners as biological parents have been reported in the news.

In one, two women in a same sex marriage wished to share in the experience of carrying their child. One of the women donated eggs. Donor sperm was used to fertilize the women's eggs outside of her body. The resulting embryos were then placed into a special device and incubated in her body. When the embryos were ready, they were transplanted into the womb of the woman who had not provided the eggs. In summary, the genetic mother of the child donated her eggs and incubated the embryos. The non-genetic mother carried the baby to term.

Will the law recognize both women as the child's biological parent? The facts challenge our notions of what it is to be a biological parent. Biological parents share genetic material with their offspring. They often share physical characteristics such as hair, eye, and skin color, height, and build.

On the other hand, surrogacy has been around since embryos could be created outside of a womb and transferred to a woman willing to bear them. Those surrogates often consider the resulting children to be their own. They often form emotional bonds with the child during pregnancy.

In Louisiana, the notion that a woman who gives birth to a child is that child's parent is strong. The strength of this notion is reflected in the black letter law. In Louisiana, a woman's agreement to give up a child born of surrogacy upon its birth is an absolute nullity unless the surrogate, her husband (if any) and the party or parties donating eggs and/or sperm strictly follow the applicable statute.

In another case, two women both provided genetic material for the embryo that was ultimately carried to term. One of the women had a genetic disease that could have threatened the health and life of any child she bore. The disease causing DNA was removed from her egg and replaced with DNA from a healthy egg from a female donor. Fertilization of that egg produced an embryo that did not bear the disease causing genetic defect. That embryo was then implanted in the womb of the woman with the genetically transmitted disease to produce a healthy child. This child had the genetic material of both women and, of course, its father. In other words, the child had three biological parents.

Does DNA make the parent? Does the child's residence in the mother's body matter? No reported Louisiana case addresses these precise issues. If you are in a same sex relationship and considering the use of in vitro fertilization with or without a surrogate, you should consult with an attorney beforehand. Mr. Cosenza can advise you concerning the issues you may have to deal with and any statutes that may affect your decisions.

What Our Clients Say
★★★★★
I highly recommend Louis
I hired Louis to represent me in my custody battle. From the start he was upfront and honest with me, if he said he was going to do something he did it and he never attempted to settle for anything less than what I was asking. He was not afraid to go head to head with opposing counsel which is what we ended up having to do. Thanks to Louis and his experience and knowledge of family law we won our case. I highly recommend Louis and will always use him for my future family Court needs.
Caleb
★★★★★
Brilliant Mind and Excellent Communication
I had no idea how to even look for an attorney when I found myself needing one. Mr. Cosenza is the best attorney I have encountered, and I took a lot of time finding one. He is brilliant in matters of the law. He approached my case from every angle. I am so thankful he was my attorney. I started out knowing absolutely nothing about court related matters. He answered even my smallest questions and guided me through to understand what was best for me and my children. He was excellent in communication with quick replies. He will have all of my recommendations.
Becky
★★★★★
Attorney Cosenza at his craft
My journey with Mr. Cosenza began nearly 3 years ago when I contacted him about divorce proceedings. During our initial consultation he told me exactly what to expect and we discussed cost, which I thought reasonable. After retaining him as my attorney and finalizing my divorce, things became fairly intense during the negotiation of the property settlement; yet he was relentless and tenacious. In the end, we prevailed victorious and everything came together perfectly. Attorney Cosenza always responded in a timely manner to my many calls, emails and texts. He gave clear, detailed, rational explanations of what I could expect. His work on my case has been life changing, in the best way possible. I am forever in his debt.
Sean
★★★★★
He does his very best
Working with Louis Cosenza truly helped to make my very difficult emotional and legal situation feel much more comfortable as I knew his experience and expertise was there to support and guide me. He knows the law and he does his very best to use that knowledge to represent his clients in and out of the courtroom.
Craig
★★★★★
Hands down the best experience I’ve had with a lawyer
I would like to start by saying I am from TX and my ex wife tried to file a judgment in LA. I contacted a number of lawyers that explained to me that this maybe a process that they could look into. I spoke with Mr. Cosenza with his 30 plus year of experience and he assured me this was not going to be a issue. He was very informative on the proceedings that where going to take place. He couldn’t have called it any better. There wasn’t even a need for me to travel to show in court. It is definitely worth a little extra to hire one of the best. I hope I hope won’t be needing his help again but if I do need another lawyer in LA. I won’t hesitate to contact him and he will be my lawyer again.
Michael